S.A.R. Gardezi ( Department of Surgery, K.E. Medical College and Mayo Hospital, Lahore. )
Abdul Majeed Chaudhary ( Department of Surgery, K.E. Medical College and Mayo Hospital, Lahore. )
Ghulam Akbar Sial ( Department of Surgery, K.E. Medical College and Mayo Hospital, Lahore. )
Ijaz Ahmad ( Department of Surgery, K.E. Medical College and Mayo Hospital, Lahore. )
Naweed Bhatti ( Department of Surgery, K.E. Medical College and Mayo Hospital, Lahore. )
Suhail Arif ( Department of Surgery, K.E. Medical College and Mayo Hospital, Lahore. )
Shehlah Haroon ( Department of Pathology, K.E. Medical College, Lahore. )
September 1982, Volume 32, Issue 9
Original Article
Abstract
Fifty acute surgical cases were treated with Metronidazole where mixed growth of anaerobic and aerobic bacteria was isolated in a trial conducted in North Surgical Ward, Mayo Hospital. Satisfactory results were obtained in majority of cases treated with combination therapy of Metronidazole and broad spectrum antibiotics. Furthermore the post-operative wound infection was reduced considerably thus shortening the convalescence and stay period in hospital. The side effects were few and not of serious consequence. These results were compared With similar surgical procedures without the use of Metronidazole. It was found that Metronidazole produces marked reduction in the profile of post-operative complications when used in combination with other antibiotics effective against aerobes. Metronidazole has no effect against aerobic infections (JPMA 32:201, 1982).
Material and Methods
The cases included in the trial were those met in general surgical practice, where anaerobic infection was suspected on clinical grounds. Presence of foul smelling pus, gas bubbles in the wound and poor response of the infection to ordinary broad spectrum anti-biotics were the criteria used for selection of cases (Table I).
In some of these patients cultures were negative both for aerobes and anaerobes.
The analysis of cases included in the trial is shown in Table II.
9 patients i.e., 18% needed a change of antibiotics after the receipt of culture and sensitivity report. All patients received Metronidazole in addition to other antibiotics as shown in Table III.
Metronidazole was used in standard doses of 500 mg, intravenously 8 hourly for a minimum period of 2 days and maximum 5 days. This was followed by oral administration. The decision to change to oral form was made on clinical grounds. Age variatior of the patients was 18-62 years. Sex incidence was 32 males and 18 females (Table IV, Fig. I).
All the patients were carefully monitored for any adverse reactions. A four hourly temperature, pulse and blood pressure were recorded 4 hourly. Wound examination was performed on 2nd, 4th and 7th day in all patients and more frequently if needed. The patients data were checked regarding comfort of wound, edema, smell, induration and discharge. Any unpleasant side- efficts were recorded according to the pa-timt's statement. Repeated examination was done for any skin rashes, inco-ordination of movements furring of tongue or darkening of urine.
Cultures and sensitivity studies were carried cut in 42 patients both aerobically and anaerobi-cally. Fluid from the hernial sac or gangrenous bowel and pus were the materials used. In patients with septic shock, blood cultures were carried out The specimens were collected in tubes having Thioglycolate medium, and they were incubated for 48 hours. In cases where copious pus was available, the tube was completely filled and immediately transported to the lab. It was incubated for 48 hours for anaerobes at 3"/°C for study of anaerobes. Streaking was done on blood agar plates and incubated in Mcintosh Field's Jar. Colonies were further differentiated by using sugars and other chemical reagents. In the remaining cases diagnosis was made on clinical criteria already mentiened.
Introduction
Metronidazole was first introduced in the treatment of infections caused by Trichomonas vaginalis (Gosar and Julou, 1959)1. Later on it was reported to be effective in the treatment of Vincent's gingivitis (Shinn, 1962) and a variety of other diseases, like tropical ulcers, amoebic dysentery and amoebic liver abscess (Buck etal., 1978). It was also found to be effective in the treatment for infections by anaerobic bacteria, particularly Bacteroides species.
The drug is well absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract. It has a wide range of bactericidal activity against a number of anaerobic bacteria.
After administration, 20% of the drug is bound with plasma and is not effective biologically. The remaining 80% is in free form and acts as an antimicrobial agent. It is partly metabolized in the liver (Ings et al., 1966) showed that approximately 60-70% of the drug is excreted unchanged in the urine. The kidneys are the main organ from where elimination takes place. The plasma half life is 6-8 hours and a single 200 mg oral dose produces a mean peak level of 5 ug/ml at 1-2 hours, falling to lug/ml after 24 hours (Welling and Munro, 1972). Single doses of Ig and 2.4g produce peak levels of about 26 and 45 ug/ml respectively. Biliary tract is not the route of excretion though therapeutic levels may be achieved in bile (Lykkegarrd et al., 1977). Normally intestinal flora is not markedly changed by the drug hence it is unlikely to cause vitamin deficiencies. It enters all tissues of the body and is present in the liver, breast milk, amniotic fluid and C.S.F. Metronidazole has been shown to inhibit the electron-transport system in Trichomonas vaginalis which probably explains its selective action against anaerobic bacteria (Edwards and Mathison, 1970).
The object of the trial was to assess that:
1. In surgical practice anaerobes are a very important cause of sepsis and are mostly of endogenous origin.
2. The administration of Metronidazole in the pre and immediate post-operative period plays a more vital role than waiting for infections to get established and then start the drug.
3. Due to obvious difficulties of anaerobic culture and urgency of correct treatment in serious cases anaerobic infections should also be diagnosed clinically i.e., by the presence of foul smelling pus and resistance to routine antibiotics.
4. Wherever possible, micro-organisms should be cultured both aerobically and anaerobically and sensitivity to various anti-biotics established.
5. Metronidazole has a significant role in the treatment of anaerobic infections and in the prevention of these in the post-operative period, particularly with Bacteroides fragilis.
6. Metronidazole is well tolerated, and safe and therapeutically effective blood levels are rapidlyachieved by its intravenous use.
Results
Majority of patients showed a satisfactory response. 8 patients died during the trial due to severe toxemia and fulminating infection. Details are given in Table V.
Almost 50% of cases suffering from the fulminating infection like typhoid perforations, Gram-ve septicemia and gangrene of bowel could be saved by Metronidazole therapy. Whereas the previous such cases showed almost 70% mortality. The results of various bacteriological studies are given in Table VI and Fig. 2.
Therapeutic efficacy of the drug was assessed on the basis of the criteria as shown in table VII.
8 patients complained of unpleasant taste in the mouth while 4 patients had upper G.I.T. upset. Only 2 patients developed a skin rash. In none of the patients the side-effects were so severe as to necessitate stoppage of the therapy. All the side effects were transient.
A comparative assessment of the clinical response to Metronidazole was done against results of similar operations in the past year in which only broad spectrum antibiotics were used.
The comparative results are given in Table IX and percentage of wound infection is shown in Figure 4.
It is evident from the table that Metronidazole used in conjunction with broad spectrum drugs significantly reduces post operative complications and mortality.
Discussion
Anaerobic bacteria have always been important pathogens for human infections. The recent rapid rise in the reported frequency of anaerobic infection over the last two decades is attributed to sophisticated techniques for the isolation of anaerobic bacteria combined with an increased awareness of their presence.
Anaerobic bacteria are the normal inhabitants of the intestine, urinary tract, female genital tract, upper respiratory tract and lungs (Lees and McNaught, 1959). They may get an entry into devitalised tissue and cause serious and occasionally fatal infections. They are also seen in many diverse surgical conditions like acute appendicitis,peritonitis due to gangrenous or perforated bowel, brain, lungs and liver abscesses, septic abortions and post operative wound and chest infections.
Early recognition and institution of appropriate therapy may help to avoid unnecessary complications. Out of various drugs like chloramphenicol, clindamycin, carbenicillin and tetracyclines, metronidazole stands out as the most effective and least toxic drug against anaerobes (Long et al., 1975).
Its availability as an intravenous preparation has further contributed towards its effective use in pre and immediate post operative period when oral therapy is not possible for obvious reasons. Gulaid et al. (1978) showed that higher concentrations in the range of 14 to 60 ug/ml are achieved at the end of intravenous infusion. The low incidence of serious side effects has made it a drug of choice against anaerobic infections. Since it is not effective against aerobes its use in combination with broad spectrum antibiotic is recommended.
The difficulty in isolation of anaerobic bacteria necessitates awareness of clinical criteria for diagnosing anaerobic infections. Metronidazole has an effective role in post operative management of acute surgical cases and has reduced the post operative complications in colonic surgery if used in bowel preparation (Taylor, 1979).
The difficulty in the isolation of anaerobic organisms necessitates that the anaerobic sepsis should be diagnosed clinically.
Metronidazole should be started on the fulfilment of the clinical criteria or when positive culture reports are available. It can also be used routinely in post operative management of acute appendicitis, peritonitis and large bowel surgery in conjunction with other broad-spectrum antibiotics to the advantage of the serious surgical cases.
Acknowledgement
The authors are grateful for their help and assistance to Dr. S. N. H. Kazmi, Dr. Masood Rashid, Medical Officers and Dr. Azam Yousaf, Registrar, North Surgical Unit. Thanks are also due to Mr. Abdul Ghaffar Naeem of Postgraduate Medical Institute, Lahore.
References
1. Buck, E., Hermanson, J. and Wickman, M. (1978) Metronidazole in treatment of liver abscess due to bacteroides fragilus. Scandanavian J. Infect. Dis., 10:152.2
2. Cosar, C. and Julou, I.. (1959) Activite del (hydroxy-2 Ethyl)-1 methyl-2 Nitro-5-imidazolc . (8,823 R.P.) vis-a-vis des infections experimentales a Trichomonias vaginalis. Ann. Inst. Pasteur., 96:238.
3. Edwards, D.I. and Mathison, G.E. (1970) The mode of action of metronidazole in trichomonas vaginalis. T. Gen. Microbiology, 63:297.
4. Gulaid, A., Houghton, G.W., Lewellen, O.R.W., Smith J. Thome. (1978) Determination of Metronidazole and its two major metabolites in Biological Fluids by high-pressure liquid chromatography. Br. J. Clin. Pharmacol., 6:430.
5. Ings, R.N., J. Law, G.L. and Parnell, E.W. (1966) The metabolism of metronidazole. Biochemical pharmacology, 15:515.
6. Lees, A.W. and McNaught, W. (1959) Bacteriology of lower-respiratory tract secretions, sputum, and upper-respiratory-tract secretions in "normals\'\' and chronic bronchitics. Lancet, 2:1112.
7. Long, S.S., Muellers, Swenson, R.M. (1975) Antibiotic susceptibilities of subspecies of B. fragitus. 15th Interscience Conference on anti-microbial agents and chemotherapy. 24-26 Sept. 1975. Washington D.C. Abs. 381.
8. Lykkegarrd, Nielson, Justesen, T. (1977) Excretion of Metronidazole in human bile. Scand. J. Gastroenterology, 12:1003.
9. Shinn, D.L.S. (1962) Metronidazole in acute ulcerative gingivitis. Lancet, 1:1191.
10. Taylor, S.A. (1979) The use of metronidazole in the preparation of the bowel for surgery. Br. J. Surg., 66:191.
11. Welling, P.G.M., Munro, A. (1972) The pharmacokinetics of Metronidazole in man. Arzneimettel forsch., 22:2128
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association has agreed to receive and publish manuscripts in accordance with the principles of the following committees: